Skip to content

조회 수 4507 추천 수 0 댓글 1
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

가 크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄 수정 삭제
?

단축키

Prev이전 문서

Next다음 문서

가 크게 작게 위로 아래로 댓글로 가기 인쇄 수정 삭제
Insider Perspective               
Seven Reasons Why Korea Has the Worst Productivity in the OECD                               
Drunk Korean businessmen play in a water fountain on a Seoul street in 2009. (Photo by Ingmar Zahorsky via Flickr)
 
17 March 2014

Korea was recently named the worst place for worker productivity in the OECD, which was featured in a recent article by this magazine. This news is not surprising for any professional previously or currently working in Korea, as the notorious overtime hours coupled with years of low growth have been a widely-discussed issue over the past few years. 

So why are Korean workers, and therefore companies, apparently so unproductive? One big reason is a lack of time management skills in the general workforce. I was employed for over a year as the Global Human Resources officer of Donghwa Holdings, and was completely immersed in the office culture, speaking only Korean as one of only two foreign employees in the Seoul office. This immersion afforded me an inside view of the time management issues plaguing Korean offices. Based on my experiences, I have developed a list of 7 reasons why Korea has the worst productivity in the OECD.

1. Rigid Structures and Hierarchy

Michael Kocken hosts an Australia-Korea businesses event at the JW Marriott Seoul during his tenure in Korea.Michael Kocken hosts an Australia-Korea businesses event at the JW Marriott Seoul during his tenure in Korea.

Korean corporate structures are notorious for their top-down approach and rigidity. Some experts even compare corporate Korea to an army division, such is the influence of military service and authoritarian leadership on the corporate landscape. 

A byproduct of such rigid corporate structures is constant and unnecessary reporting to senior directors, as soldiers to a superior officer. Teams will brief department heads weekly, and sometimes even the board of executives on a regular basis. Also, if a director wants to know about something, regardless of whether it is of concern to their project goals, a team leader will be forced to present a report to the directors, usually within a very short timeframe. The team leader will then drop whatever team-related work they were doing and have their team spend the next few days researching and preparing an over-the-top presentation for the director. 

This constant cycle of ad hoc reporting ensures that there is little strategic work and movement within a company. Instead, the corporate environment feels like a fire department, where teams are always on-call for spot fires, and need to be ready to respond to unexpected problems immediately. From experience, my previous company was a never-ending merry-go-round of audits and presentations, which resulted in my team leader spending the majority of his time making PowerPoint presentations for the CEO, a situation he himself would lament as a waste of his time.

2. Communication Issues

Despite an enforced culture of regular drinking and socializing, Korean companies suffer from a lack of direct, honest, and effective communication. Teams themselves and departments will often function fairly well together. But the atmosphere of constant socializing by eating lunch together and after-hours drinking sessions has created the side effect of factions within a company. As a result, teams across departments become almost enemies. Inter-departmental links are non-existent, and business units within one company become suspicious and competitive. Poor communication always results in poor performance, and when there are poor interdepartmental relationships, performance suffers even more.

English communication is also a major issue at Korean corporations. Many Koreans, frustrated with the emphasis on English in their country, will question the necessity of English when they never use it in the workplace. Most Koreans think that learning English is only useful as a means to communicate with foreign business partners, or for use in business emails. But they overlook the fact that a world of resources and knowledge (case studies, annual reports, professional tips) is available to them via the Internet predominantly in English, and only a fraction of what is out there has been translated thus far into Korean. Foreign workers will always have the advantage of a simple Google search, which can provide hundreds to thousands of alternative information sources to what is available to a Korean limited to searching in Korean on a portal such as Naver. 

3. Mobile Phones and Online Communication

Korea is a truly connected society with a fantastic broadband network providing some of the fastest Internet and LTE coverage in the world to its businesses. However, the ease and preference for communicating online or through a messaging app on a phone is becoming a real issue in the workplace. Levels upon levels of an office building are so silent that they sound like a library. Everyone is tapping away furiously at their workstations, and you can easily presume it’s because everyone is working very hard. But check a screen and you’ll see that most workers are engaging in some form of online messaging, whether it be Kakaotalk’s desktop version, Microsoft, LYNC, or Nateon. Workers will normally be chatting away to office buddies - occasionally about work, but more often than not just wasting time. A silent rule of Korean society is that talking in the office gives off the appearance of not working, and so workers are forced to send messages via the Internet, even if the person they want to talk to happens to be sitting right next to them. If it’s not the online messengers, then it’s the mobile phones. Workers seem to check them every ten minutes or simply get up to go out to receive a personal phone call. 

In a recent survey of 706 office workers by job search portal Career.co.kr, it found that over 61 percent of respondents said they have a resting place at work. Of these 61 percent, a quarter said that they would escape to the toilets, with just under 45 percent responding that they use their phone during this time for games, Internet, SMS, and phone calls. Go into any office building toilet in Seoul and you will hear mobile message tones or game sounds going off like firecrackers.

4. Hungover Workers Taking Excessive Breaks

Korean companies encourage and pay for workers to enjoy after-hour dinners and drinks together on a regular basis, believing that it improves loyalty and interpersonal communication between workers. The only requirement is that they are at work the next day (preferably on time). It’s amazing after all these years that bonding is still considered the most important aspect to a well-functioning team, and regular hangovers are just a small inconvenience. 

Staff may as well not be at work the next day because a heaving, red-eyed, headache-ridden shell of what used to be a fully-functional worker is going to be useless for the entire next day without proper rest and recovery from the night before.

Smoking too is also a major issue affecting productivity. I do support the notion that workers benefit from regular rest breaks to get out of their seat to stretch and refresh, but the time taken to smoke is so great that non-smokers often feel that they are losing out, because they will effectively be spending, on average, 1 hour a day longer at their desks. Eventually the non-smokers catch on and begin to take 3 to 4 coffee breaks a day to also enjoy their extra hour of rest a day. In the same study by website Career.co.kr, it also found that nearly half of the 708 respondents would leave their desks to go to a rest spot three or four times a day. They would stay there for an average of 13 minutes. 

5. Form Rules Over Substance

During my time at a Korean company, one of the observations that I made was that co-workers would spend two to three days adding in an array of fancy-looking shapes, images, flow charts, and graphs to a PowerPoint presentation that contained roughly half a day of research. That is the power of perception in the Korean office, and it forces workers to spend ridiculous amounts of time “beautifying” simple reports that would take 10 minutes to present in an informal meeting or chat. 

This penchant for giving off a favorable impression exists in most company teams and departments in the form of “Yes” men and women. These employees whose prerogative is to give off a favorable impression to their superiors will sacrifice personal opinions and honest feedback for the sake of appearing loyal and subordinate. Even if this gesture of loyalty is shallow and fake, it is still appreciated over genuine communication. Often did I witness co-workers blindly repeat “yes, yes, yes” to a senior employee’s orders without the slightest query as to “why” or “how,” leaving them with little understanding of the work they were agreeing to do, and eventually a resentment towards the ones giving the orders.

6. Poorly-equipped, Older Graduates

Korean graduate employees, despite extreme competition for jobs, are under-prepared for the workplace, and come with poor research and reporting skills. This is a side effect of an education system based around testing and lack of practical applications. Many young graduates come into the workforce with next-to-zero work experience, bar a few obligatory volunteer activities. 

This is astounding, especially considering a recent survey conducted by the Dong-A Ilbo and recruitment website Incruit.com, which found that the average age of new workers in Korea was a staggering 33.2 years of age for men (up from 27.3 in 2008) and 28.6 years of age for females. The advanced age of new Korean workers compared to the West is a result of 2 years of mandatory military service for men, international gap years during university, and extra years spent studying for various certificates and qualifications viewed as essential for employment.

What that process creates is a workforce of 30-somethings with no job experience and unrealistic expectations of work and money.  A 30-year-old Western applicant of similar age has almost 10 years of real work experience over a Korean, and there is no amount of education that can substitute for that kind of difference. Such is the disillusionment with company life that recruitment website Saramin last year found that a staggering 3 in 10 new employees quit within the first year of employment, with the majority citing that their jobs roles didn’t match their aptitudes - another sign that graduate employees are not prepared for the realities of the workforce.

7. The Art of Looking Busy

In business or social situations both, Koreans have a penchant for giving off the impression of being busy. Rarely will you meet a Korean that will say they have relaxed recently. Being busy is the desired state and worn as a badge of honor. 

This leads to Korean workers staying late, much later than any of their OECD counterparts, to give the impression of being busy. Unfortunately, staying late at the office does not equate into greater productivity, and although Korean work colleagues will claim to be very busy at work, the reality is that most are over-exaggerating their workload, which brings Parkinson’s law of time into effect.

Parkinson’s law is the adage which states that “work expands so as to fill the time available for its completion.” The Korean workforce all know that they will be expected to work overtime hours whether they have work or not - it’s again another test of perception, loyalty, and social pressure. So what naturally occurs is the application of Parkinson’s law. Why finish your work by 5 o’clock when you know you will be at the office until 10 or 11 anyways? 

I believe that this style of thinking is one of the biggest hurdles in overcoming the unproductive work culture in Korea. Korean workers must be honest with themselves in the fact that they are sometimes not really that busy, but that does not make them lazy. Focusing on your work, finishing it on time, and going home on time is in fact the reverse of a lazy worker. This idea needs to be recognized and enforced in the Korean workplace.

I hope I was able to provide a little bit more insight into what issues some Korean companies are dealing with, and some reasons as to why Korea has low productivity. Of course, this is a subjective view based on my experience in a Korean work environment, but it can perhaps provide some insights to others who wonder about the floor-level view of the OECD evaluation.

A lot of the issues I have outlined are not unique to Korea, and quite rightly exist in Western companies too. However, they can be magnified in South Korea due to the deep historical and cultural aspects that are ingrained into the national psyche. Hope lies in the next generation, who are undoubtedly tired of unsustainable work practices and will struggle to remove themselves from the dogma of corporate life to affect real change in the future.

by Michael Kocken, Korean Market Consultant for Kocken Consulting. Also, check out his blog, The Sawon.

- See more at: http://www.businesskorea.co.kr/article/3698/insider-perspective-seven-reasons-why-korea-has-worst-productivity-oecd#sthash.hhdAAA9Q.dpuf
  • ?
    lburtra 2014.04.24 02:19
    Thank you for the articel. It seems to be interesting and useful.

List of Articles
번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수
공지 오케이, 오늘부터 (2014년 12월 1일) 달라지는 이 누리. 29 김원일 2014.11.30 88713
공지 게시물 올리실 때 유의사항 admin 2013.04.06 116369
공지 스팸 글과 스팸 회원 등록 차단 admin 2013.04.06 131768
공지 필명에 관한 안내 admin 2010.12.05 163401
15731 민초 스다 누리에 여러분을 환영합니다. 10 김원일 2010.11.12 35679
15730 자유로운 게시판이 되길 기원합니다 1 박훈(필명) 2010.11.12 7950
15729 짜자잔 5 김주영 2010.11.12 8665
15728 감사합니다. 바오밥 2010.11.12 7746
15727 축하합니다. 2 1.5세 2010.11.12 9903
15726 쥔장님, 민초스다라는 간판이라도 답시다.?^^ 2 김민철 2010.11.12 10150
15725 아름다운 설악산 단풍 3 1.5세 2010.11.12 7810
15724 *~하늘에 영광 이누리에 축복있으라~* 2 유재춘 2010.11.12 8607
15723 축하를 하면서.. 3 바이블 2010.11.12 7938
15722 뭉치면 살고 헤어지면 죽는다 유재춘 2010.11.12 7877
15721 실명제 arirang 2010.11.12 7816
15720 @ 축하드립니다 ! ! . . 스다에 올리고 . . 가저왔습니다. 1 반달 2010.11.12 7700
15719 어떤 분들은 쉽게 가자고 합니다. 고바우생각 2010.11.13 6888
15718 울화통 치민다!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 8 울화통 치미는 자 2010.11.13 6713
15717 실명제보다 더 무서운 것 3 arirang 2010.11.13 7300
15716 흠~ 좋네요! 1 노을 2010.11.13 7966
15715 나도 한 마디 제안하면... 3 바다 2010.11.13 7733
15714 반갑고 기쁘고 고맙습니다 snow 2010.11.13 7253
15713 아스다 혹은 유스다 !! 익명 2010.11.13 7054
15712 날고파(날아 가고파) josh 2010.11.13 7020
15711 집들이 축하드리며 질문하나 드립니다. 5 파란하늘 2010.11.13 9119
15710 새 집 마련을 축하합니다. 코스모스 2010.11.13 13661
15709 민초들을 위한 사이트 개설을 환영합니다.. 익명입니다 2010.11.13 15230
15708 민초스다 2 익명 2010.11.13 44449
15707 We Pray to Thee / The King's Heralds 1.5세 2010.11.13 15369
15706 IP 주소에 관해 알리는 말씀 김원일 2010.11.13 16217
15705 신뢰와 모험: 이 누리의 기본 철학 5 김원일 2010.11.13 16912
15704 벌써 새벽 한 시여서... 1 김원일 2010.11.13 17211
15703 자유토론의장이 되길 1 익명 2010.11.14 10518
15702 예언(예지)과 예정의 차이에 대한 질문!!! 4 고바우생각 2010.11.14 10057
15701 이 누리가 양보할 수 없는 원칙 하나: 삭제에 관한 이야기 4 김원일 2010.11.14 11041
15700 카스다, 그리고 이제는 민초스다.. 4 김 성 진 2010.11.14 13169
15699 고기도 굽나요 1 붕어빵 2010.11.14 10090
15698 출석도장은 이렇게 하는 겁니다 ^^ 바다 2010.11.14 9000
15697 주변에서 맴돌기 2 자유인 2010.11.14 8269
15696 오늘은 내가 반달로 떠도 무실 2010.11.14 8141
15695 기술 관리자님께 3 김원일 2010.11.14 9312
15694 변화의 물줄기 3 노을 2010.11.14 7973
15693 민초스다에 거는 기대 주변인 2010.11.14 12089
15692 실험정신 1 새소망 2010.11.14 8297
15691 한번 장로이면 영원한 장로인가? 5 발해를 꿈꾸며 2010.11.14 8598
15690 한국의 안식일교인수는 얼마일까? 발해를 꿈꾸며 2010.11.14 8636
15689 의사와 뉴스타트와 하나님의 관계.. 고바우생각님에게.. (수정) 5 김 성 진 2010.11.14 7363
15688 쥔장, 관리자, 그리고 누리꾼 2 김원일 2010.11.14 7690
15687 오메 손가락이 부끄러붜라 12 바다 2010.11.14 7861
15686 카스다에 대해서.. 4 바이블 2010.11.14 8174
15685 호스트와 반가운 분들께 1 나비 2010.11.15 7929
15684 너무 까불다가 5 로산 2010.11.15 8224
15683 카스다와 이 누리의 대결구도 3 김원일 2010.11.15 6884
15682 인사드립니다. 1 반고 2010.11.15 7085
15681 하루를 살아도 사는 맛이 나게 살며(11월 16일 출석부) 바다님 말씀 18 로산 2010.11.15 6507
15680 물 유재춘 2010.11.15 6561
15679 자진 삭제해주신 분께 감사를 김원일 2010.11.15 6080
15678 기술 관리자 님 2 관리자 2010.11.15 6572
15677 몹시 부럽습니다, 고바우님.. 4 김 성 진 2010.11.15 5815
15676 미주한인교회협회 임원들은 그들의 결정에 대한 책임을 져야 한다.. 8 김 성 진 2010.11.15 6419
15675 민초는 2부예배 10 빨간펜 2010.11.15 5962
15674 [기술 관리자] 보다는 . . . [기술 담당자]가 어감이 좋습니다. 4 반달 2010.11.15 5946
15673 휘경동의 한 자매 . . 살아가는 솔직한 이야기 (동영상) 2 반달 2010.11.15 7073
15672 아담의 범죄와 나이 2 바이블 2010.11.16 5648
15671 아담의 살아생전 사진과 죽은 후의 사진.. 8 김 성 진 2010.11.16 5451
15670 보수론자들이 좋아라 하는 대총회장의 “네 행위를 아노니” (11.17출석) 8 로산 2010.11.16 8199
15669 세계교회라는 이름의 실상과 허상 로산 2010.11.16 5461
15668 관리자님 질문 있어요. 4 익명 2010.11.16 5316
15667 누리꾼들께 여쭙니다: 쪽지함 기능이 있는데 설치할까요? (수정) 12 김원일 2010.11.16 4558
15666 하나님의 계명을 지키며 예수의 증거를 가진...? 4 고바우생각 2010.11.16 5795
15665 고고학적 진화와 창조 3 바이블 2010.11.16 5161
15664 민초의 근본 이념과 목적을 고려해 볼때 . . .[비밀 함] 1 반달 2010.11.16 5131
15663 Hummingbird 님! . . 2 생각하는 갈대 2010.11.17 4903
15662 [로그인] 안하고도 ~ ~ ~ 연습 2010.11.17 3335
Board Pagination Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... 225 Next
/ 225

Copyright @ 2010 - 2016 Minchoquest.org. All rights reserved

Minchoquest.org

sketchbook5, 스케치북5

sketchbook5, 스케치북5